Looking for a little help from my friends

It's Garden Bloggers Bloom Day and I'll be back later with a few photos to actually participate (for the first time in months) but first I need a little help on a project.

Please note, that's a picture from the store, not one showing my growing silk clematis collection.

This is one that has been a long time coming. I picked up this dresser at the thrift store for $35 about two years ago. I bought it because I couldn't leave it there. I don't (and didn't then) have a place to put it right now, but I like it, so it will get used. Like the buffet that lived in the garage for a long time, this dresser has been languishing in our unheated, gross garage for a long time. And I've hit it with the car more than once.

The law has been laid down: I MUST start finishing some projects before I take on anything else. You can probably guess who came up with that edict, but I'm on board with it. He's right. Our house is way too small to be storing future projects. That's why I've passed up some great stuff at the thrift store (including this chair). If I can't fix it up and use it immediately, it doesn't come in the house.

Anyway, in late fall we pulled the dresser out of the garage and I got to work on sanding it. It was covered in mildew inside and stunk to high heaven. I cleaned it a bunch of times with various things including vinegar and have been letting it air out and now it's all sanded, smelling sweet and ready for the next step.

Ewww ... check out that mildew in there. People, don't leave your furniture in your garage for two years.
And that's where you come in. I want you to tell me what you think I should do with it. But this is not a no-holds-barred kind of thing. I have a general concept I'm hoping you'll help me flush out.

Because the top and sides are laminate veneer, the entire outside of it (top, sides, bottom rail, legs) is going to get painted white. If you are cringing at the thought of painting that plastic wood-type stuff, check out what I did to my desk at work. It's been well over a year and it has help up amazingly well. There's not a chip on it. But the drawers are real wood and they are sort of pretty, so I'm not going to paint those.

My inspiration to even buy this dresser started at Young House Love, where John and Sherry refinished a very similar dresser for their daughter Clara's room. They went with a dark stain and only painted the top.

Young House Love stained/painted dresser
Young House Love photo
Here's a similar finishing concept from Twenty-Six to Life.
Twenty-six to Life photo
Here's the opposite finishing from Birdhouse. The wood is sort of a medium tone, rather than dark like the examples above. Pay attention to the wood color here, not the positioning of paint vs. stain because it's not an option for me to stain the top and sides.
Birdhouse photo
Here's the reverse from Blessed Nest, again with a medium-tone stain (and amazing hardware).
Blessed Nest photo
Now we're getting slightly lighter with this one from Handmade Home.
Handmade Home photo
And even lighter on this dresser from The Lettered Cottage. Layla toned down the wood color with a little bit of gray stain, but this not too much different from the natural wood color of my dresser drawers.
The Lettered Cottage photo
And there's this one, which just gives you an idea of colors.

So, what color do you think I should go with for the stain? Since I don't know where this is going, let's just assume you don't have to worry about matching it to anything else. Logically it will end up in one of the bedrooms which, as you recall, have a darker bamboo floor in them, in case that affects your decision at all. 

This is the master bedroom, just to remind you of the floors in there.
Master bedroom -- bamboo floors, custom built-its

Let me know in the comments or on facebook what direction you think the dresser should go in.

4 comments :

  1. Oh My word!! I have no idea, but your Master bedroom is AWESOME!!!! The dresser is pretty cool also, keep us posted on your progress.... can't wait to see what you do with it... : )

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks the for nice comments on the master, Kathy. We're so happy with how it turned out and those built-ins are by far my favorite thing in the room. It's a small room but having built-in furniture and the high ceilings really makes it feel much bigger than its 11x14 footprint.

      Delete
  2. I love the color of the Blessed Nest and Birdhouse dressers. There's a warm gold tone to the stain that feels warm and cozy. I think it will breakup some of the white in the bedroom.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Erin -- I love that dresser and would have fallen into its devious clutches too!

    If it were me, I would give it a light stain for now, and live with it in the space for a while before deciding, just because that's the easiest thing to undo or cover up. But I think I have too much of a weakness for vintage furniture... I always buy it at the flea market or thrift store intending to change it up completely, but then when it comes down to it, I mostly just try to keep them as close to their previous state as possible. I'm sure you're better in your determination! :-)

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I appreciate it. I try to respond to comments here or sometimes via email so make sure to check back.